Balkanization Threatens Nepal, Discrimination driving separatism in Terai

January 31, 2007

Balkanization Threatens Nepal

Discrimination driving separatism in Terai 

The people of Nepal have been deluding themselves all along about a “new Nepal.” Who can blame them? Our politicians have been reiterating, “Nepal has already changed, it’s no longer the same old country. We are building a new Nepal.” I, too, fell for the old shibboleth of a new Nepal, but the fatal shooting of a teenager by the Maoists was therapeutic as well as traumatic. The circumstances are clear enough — one group is powerful, because armed, while the majority of Nepalese have nothing but their earnest voices and a zeal for self-rule, to break free from the old ways of oppression and injustice.Years of suppression and rank discrimination threatening newly restored peace in the country.On Monday afternoon, the phone rang repeatedly as more and more news of violence in the Terai region was coming in. “One more died here after the Armed Police Force opened fire at the protesters. The situation is tense, as the protesters have zeroed in on the police station and have started pelting it with stones,” our local correspondent said over the telephone. Another 12-hour-long curfew has been imposed on the area. Like the supposedly dormant volcano that remains quiescent until the pressure from below becomes uncontainable, it seems that the time has finally come for the Madhesi people to demand the fundamental rights they have so far been denied.At least two people lost their lives on the spot in the incident yesterday, and about two dozen of the seriously injured were taken to Kathmandu’s Bir Hospital via Nepali Army night-vision helicopter late last night for treatment. Unfortunately, two died of their injuries today. “They emphasized the involvement of Maoists, who are now all-powerful after the decade-long insurgency and bloodshed. If they (the ruling class) repeat the same mistakes, then the revolution in the Terai could cost more lives and signal the start of another people’s war,” argued Chhatra Shankar, vice president of the Human Rights Journalists’ Association-Nepal.“If the Seven-Party Alliance (SPA), including the Maoists, labels this violence in the Terai as ‘communal,’ then it would be their mistake. It is a political problem,” Shankar said, adding, “and the problem should be addressed politically.”

The Madhesi Fundamental Rights Forum-Nepal and Janatantrik Terai Mukti Morchas have been demanding autonomy for the Terai and an end to the “internal occupation of the Terai” by Nepali-speaking rulers. Nepal is divided into the Mountain, Hill and Terai ecological belts. The Terai, called the granary of Nepal because of its fertile, arable land, covers about 23 percent of the total land area, and, according to the census of 2001, 48.4 percent of the over 23 million Nepalese reside there.During my 20-year lifespan, I have experienced how being a dark-complected Madhesi (a Nepalese of Indian extraction living in the Terai) can be a curse. In addition to illiteracy and poverty, even literate Madhesis are burdened with rank discrimination just for being Terai-dwellers. “In Kathmandu, we are loathed as ‘dhotis’ (Indians), and in India, we are humiliated as ‘Nepalese’,” one of my cousins, now resident in the U.S., said, adding, “I don’t know if it’s a curse to be born as a Madhesi.”When visiting my village, located in one of the remote villages of

Nepal, in Sarlahi, I remember children of my own age taunting me, “Pahadi, Pahadi! Look, Pahadi has come with his hat,” and they would laugh at me. Then I used to wonder, what is “Pahadi”? Later, I came to know it as slang for those who live in the hills, and from then on I detested the very idea of going back to my village when I was at school in Kathmandu. I call Kathmandu home and don’t feel any sense of alienation there for this very reason.I became increasingly aware of bigotry even in the capital of my beloved country. When someone would label me “bhaiya” (big brother) or “marsiya” (a corruption of Madhesi) I used to feel bad. They have even degraded the original meaning of bhaiya and dhoti as dignified by Gandhi, the Father of India, who wore white cotton dhotis all his life. People living in the Terai also wear dhotis because of the scorching heat of the sun.I’ve been fortunate in that my complexion, accent and day-to-day behavior are no different from those of anyone else who feels proud of their ethnic identity, but as a child, “exiled” from my own people, I was influenced otherwise. But when some around me in Kathmandu pronounces Madhesi, they mangle it. When they have to point out any one hailing from the Terai, they simply stereotype all Terai people as “Marsiya” or “dhoti.” Their mispronunciation is palpably disgusting and humiliating to the Terai people. Perhaps this very inequality and discrimination gave birth to the love of my own land, which I’d long forgotten.You might not credit that as a schoolboy I imagined ways to help those put down by class oppression, even to the extent of devising a new nation of “Terai” to accommodate them. When these same people, members of the Madhesi Peoples’ Rights Forum or Janatantrik Terai Mukti Morcha, however, now demand an autonomous federal republic, I am incongruously unable to support them. Neither do I take to the idea of the movements behind Newa Mukti Morcha or the Limbuwan Federal Republic or other groups demanding self-rule.But most of these people also know that in these efforts they, and especially the Maoists, are threatening to re-balkanize

Nepal. The rebels, implementing the odious doctrine of divide and conquer, are entrapping the Nepalese into being alienated along the lines of caste and creed, into Newar, Tharu, Gurung or Limbu. Perhaps they do represent a “new” Nepal, a remake of the same old Nepal, in which different groups fought every other day, living in constant fear of each other. Have they ever considered that there are those belonging to other castes and races within their “own” area as well — how would they deal with them? I wonder if they even begin to know the meaning of tolerance. At such a critical time, the violence in the Terai can only arouse the Madhesi people because the chair or the members of Central Committee of the CPN-Maoist and other major political parties in the country are also Khas-speaking (Nepali-speaking) people. It is also clear that the country is not going to have a Madhesi prime minister in the foreseeable future. The leaders then have the difficult task of uniting the whole country in the face of their own dictum of divide and rule. I wonder if the bloodshed really came to an end with the comprehensive peace accord or is now just the beginning of a new wave?source::http://eng.ohmynews.com/articleview/article_view.asp?menu=c10400&no=341574&rel_no=1

Entry Filed under: Articles. .

10 Comments Add your own

  • 1. by Salik Shah  |  February 4, 2007 at 6:33 pm

    Published in Ohmynews International and Orato.

  • 2. Son of Tirhut  |  March 23, 2007 at 1:52 pm

    I agree with this article but afterall we need autonomous state that belongs to Madhesi people.

    Jai Madhes!!!!!

  • 3. Ravi  |  July 7, 2007 at 12:42 am

    Upon reading the article, this seems to be a very genuine and touchable, the writer has felt his pit of the heart while behaving like this way. Every social groups upon living in certan geographic area form a ethnic boundary, what Barthes have said determines their position in the Social Milieu. Lowly educated people are more ethnicentric. They immediately distinguish what is different between them and other group of people. So there appears discrimination and differences. Writer’s essay has portrayed a live picture of what is a psychological identity of a Madhesi people. Even some one point of the racial element in such behaviours. Why such remarks are put by the Pahade People.

    1. Pahade People frequently hear the news of Boarder encroachment and take over by the Indian Boarder Security Guards in Terai. This hurts them, why the Indian Armies Troubles the poor Nepal? This is the simple question every one ask with his self. Is there no place for a Poor Country like Nepal who can live in a dignified way being a sovereign Land of the world? A Nepalese citizen in Kathmandu finds Indian Police/Army freely coming with Arms to pay Homage to Pashupatinath. So this is a disrespect for the Nepalese people. They have been hurt deeply. The high dams built along the Terai brings problem of flood, so maks huge lake brings chaos in the lives of people in Terai.

    There are many issues between India and Nepal, that makes Nepalese people sad and angry. Pahades never go to their own fellows land in Madesh, so they donot know what are their social and economic indicators. So being black in color and wearing Dhoti they take them Indians, so they spill their anger to them remembering what Indian policies have brought problems in the National Identity of Nepal.

    The bad behaviours to nepalese when they are in Boardering cities even brings another anger and hatred among the Pahades. Daily news comes about the misbehaviour, looting of the Nepalese coming to home from work by the BSF. Once Nepalese Pahade driver was killed by the angry mob when hitting a rikshaw. Even policment didnot take concern that time. The incident happend in the boardering town near Nepalgunj. So many news comes in the media where Pahdes are misbehaved, ill treated, looted etc. Numerous events help ot solidify to misbehave the black looking people in Pahad. So this brings such proplem to the People of Terai/Madhesh. This is a sure crazy activity.

    2. my next concern to the write up is that, Every Nepalese citizen is now seriously thinking of this social exculsion. They have known that how far are the people hurted…….. This had brought a kind of shame, even to the common citizen. Common people have felt the demands of the Terai people.

    3. I hope we can all find a better solution to heal the sentiment of the Madhesi People in a dignified manner. Political analyst have found up that the crux of Madhesi Movement is two-fold. Once is the crisis of Identity and another social exclusion and maltreatment by Kathmandu.

    Lets talk about the discrimination, prejudices and inequailty. Lets make a dialogue to find a lasting solution. If we think of Gandhi, then lets not forget about his principal of non-voilence. Lets not fight with eachother and let’s make our society peaceful. The artificial boundary of Nation is not important if we can build up a long alliance with every people of this world.

  • 4. praksh  |  February 15, 2008 at 3:02 am

    Madhesh does not exist in Nepal’s history, geography: Keshav Prasad Mainali PDF Print E-mail
    Thursday, 07 February 2008

    BY BN DAHAL

    HIGHT LIGHT

    Those who had come from the Madhya Pradesh of India and settled here are called Madhesis and tarai is not Madhesh. I am puzzled why those who are in power and the big parties are giving so much importance to Madhesh and the Madhesis.

    The government does not care about it. It is not heard that this country should not be divided in Susta. But when talk about this to the leaders, they say the bigger fish swallows the smaller one. They also say, one should not quarrel with the neighbour for a few metres of land. This also confirmed our fear that the country is heading towards division. Our Chure-Bhavar is pushing its own agenda and issue. We don’t accept any Madhesh in the Terai and we are working with all our might for national integrity.

    Issues, like secularism and religion, republic and federalism should only be decided by the government and parliament that has received the fresh mandate of the people. What right the government and the parliament that was picked up and selected has to decide on those issues. This is only a ploy to make the parliament that has gained the people’s mandate a mere rubber stamp.

    What kind of representative will we be electing on the votes given by those who are not the real citizens of this country? We are doubtful about whose vested interest will be fulfilled by this. We have also talked about sealing the border because there are elements from across the border coming into Nepal and involved in killing, murder, abduction and others. We must be free from fear of bullet and threats. The CA election should only be done after meeting our 9-point demand.

    ImageKeshav Prasad Mainali is chairman of the Chure-Bhabar Ekata Party. He got involved in politics in 2024 BS from Nepal Student Union and he was also president of the Nepali Congress’s Sarlahi district committee. Mainali talked to People’s Review on the existing political situation and especially focusing on the tarai agitations and movement.

    Q. The Chure-Bhabhar Ekata Samaj had suddenly come into limelight and now it has remained quiet and even looked complacent? Why is it?

    A. We have not remained quiet. Any group is in the limelight if it is into agitation. But now we are forming our own militia, that is why we look to be quiet and complacent, which we are not.

    Q. Why are you forming militia group?

    A. The unnecessary agitations and movements in the tarai has endangered the country’s unity, integrity and nationalism. Therefore, to prevent the country from splitting up and to raise arms if necessary we are forming our own militia.

    Q. How do you look at the Madhesi’s movement in the tarai?

    A. There are attempts to break up the country in the name of tarai movements. No constitution of Nepal has mentioned the name Madhesh. Therefore, there are attempts to create terror and panic by bringing in the word Madhesh, which does not exist in our constitution and law. We oppose this. Those who had come from the Madhya Pradesh of India and settled here are called Madhesis and tarai is not Madhesh. I am puzzled why those who are in power and the big parties are giving so much importance to Madhesh and the Madhesis.

    Q. You say when there is no Madhesh, how can there be Madhesis, but the government has already accepted their existence?

    A. This is the irony and absurdity. The government has accepted the existence of something which is not there in reality. Therefore, those who are in power are creating division in the country. When we tried to find the origin of Madhesh, we found in a dictionary the word Madhesh, according to which Madhesh is an area in Mohat of India. We have not accepted any area called Mohat in India. Now, in our agitation we will burn the page of the constitution which contains the word Madhesh because one cannot create separation in the country by using the word which does not exist.

    Q. Then what is the agitation that is raging in Madhesh?

    A. The present agitation in Madhesh is a separatist movement. Earlier, we had called it as the movement against the Pahadis and the Madhesis. But those who are the new arrivals in tarai and calling themselves as the dhartiputra (sons of the soil) are into chasing people of the hill origin and who had been permanently settled there. Therefore, it is a separatist movement. When people like Rajendra Mahato, who despite being in the government, chanted ‘Pahadis go to the hills or on the other side of the Chure’, it clearly oozes the smell of separatism. But the government does not care about it. It is not heard that this country should not be divided in Susta. But when talk about this to the leaders, they say the bigger fish swallows the smaller one. They also say, one should not quarrel with the neighbour for a few metres of land. This also confirmed our fear that the country is heading towards division. Our Chure-Bhavar is pushing its own agenda and issue. We don’t accept any Madhesh in the tarai and we are working with all our might for national integrity.

  • 5. Raju  |  June 14, 2008 at 12:50 am

    The Madeshis are Indian animals
    we should deport every last one of them and build a wall between nepal and that piece of shit under us.

  • 6. karki  |  June 27, 2008 at 7:28 pm

    diese madhesis don’t deserve to be called nepalese ,at this critical time ,they want to divide the country
    no to autonomous terai ,

  • 7. nepali  |  July 20, 2008 at 7:40 am

    social exclusion is terrible. That seems to be the essence of all Nepals troubles. Karma of oppression created this endless fighting. So no one ever stops fighting and the country is destroying more?
    Now blame the congress party and king and previous government, probably it all takes time. Process seems to be that at least madhesi are more than maoists which nobody reallly seems to mind put something to rule, kick it and another and kick again this is called POLITICAL INSTABILITY.

  • 8. madhesi  |  August 7, 2008 at 6:53 am

    Its funny the few comentators above don’t even know the history of Nepal….which came together in its present form only during the late 1700’s…..and madhesis are not from madhya pradesh lol the name Madhya Pradesh didnot exist until the 1960’s madhesis i.e maithili, awadhi and bhhojpuri speakers have been in the terai or madesh even before terai became part of Nepal….remember entire western terai was under kindoms of Awadh and Rohillas….the nawab of awadh controlled it until the british took over. In fact Paharis are the only recent migrants to Madhesh. Just because terai is now attached to a kingdom dominated by paharis doesnot mean that terai dwellers/madhesis can be ignored or overlooked.

  • 9. Roshan kumar jha,KSL, Rautahat, Gaur  |  July 10, 2009 at 4:55 am

    You pahadis are Bhagauda. you came from the capital of ancient madhesh “Kanakubj” so all are pure madhesis. we madhesis people have a long history of independent. But you pahadia always suppressed us. We are nor indians we are the real inhabitants of terai.

    So you pahadis who gave you authority to call us indian animals. if you use this word time and again. i will kill you understand sale

  • 10. one  |  August 8, 2009 at 6:50 am

    Imagine there’s no countries
    It isn’t hard to do
    Nothing to kill or die for
    And no religion too
    Imagine all the people
    Living life in peace…

    i love you all madhesis, paharis, janajatis, dalits, tharus, indians, chinese

Leave a Comment

Required

Required, hidden

Some HTML allowed:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


Celebration of 1,00,000

New begining

Watch videos at Vodpod and other videos from this collection.

Madhesi Voice

Analyst

Internal Institutions Comments

Saluting Martyrs

Letter Petition & Memorandum

Nepalganj Incident Video

United We Celebrate

People Celebrating faguwa (Holi), with the fun of music, quite popular among Terai people. Holi is celebrated each year on the eve of falgun purnima Faguwa (Holi) Celebration

Recent Posts

Past Posts

Recent Comments

pankaj jha on Personalities
raju tamag on MUSLIMS of NEPAL: Becoming an …
Ram Vinod Mahato on Madheshi Women’s Future: What…
shekh mohd shahid am… on Organizations
sudhir mishra on Udit Narayan (Jha)

Archives