Still a mess

January 23, 2009 at 3:32 am 4 comments

Still a mess


Two years after the Madhes movement altered Nepali nationalism, the Tarai is in a mess.

Anger against Kathmandu was the defining feature of this period. Now, a mix of disillusionment, rage, helplessness and fear prevails. Macro politics in the region is more fragmented than ever, across party and caste lines. And at the micro level violence has become the only tool to resolve both political and personal disputes.

In terms of party politics, the MJF managed to prevent a split this week. All leaders realised they needed each other (Upendra needs Gachhedar’s Tharu base and JP’s manipulative skills, and both recognise that Upendra remains the face of the Madhes movement).

All this is happening as the polarisation in national politics deepens. With inter-party relations improving somewhat in Kathmandu, the mood at Bhadrakali, Maharajganj and Lainchaur will continue to determine MJF realignments.

The TMDP has begun protests demanding implementation of the eight-point agreement. Apart from a few committed activists, people are in no mood to come out into the streets. But this is a chance for the party to expand its organisation and caste base, get its leaders out into the Tarai and occupy the moral high ground.

There is a churning among the armed groups. The government talks drama has had a few unintended consequences: intermediaries have made money, ragtag groups have gained legitimacy, some serious groups have been forced to introspect and the security situation has become even weaker with the police told not to upset the process.

There are mixed signals about the unification of the three armed groups. Goit, Jwala and Pawan’s representative, Azad, did meet in Patna last week to get together but whether this translates on the ground is to be seen. All three are planting different versions of the meeting.

Jwala unilaterally issued a statement saying Goit would be a ‘ceremonial’ head, Pawan deputy chairman, while he would be general secretary and the military commander. Goit immediately refuted the statement. Pawan’s other representative, Kautilya, who has been talking to the government, rejected the efforts. Either Pawan is playing both sides (talking to the state while strengthening the armed movement) or has a genuine problem balancing the contradictory impulses within.

If all this is not confusing enough, add the Maoist and Matrika dimension. The biggest challenge for the Maoists would be a cohesive Madhes. The present fragmentation gives them ample opportunities to play off one against the other. Control of the state apparatus has allowed them to build links with key actors, both mainstream Madhesi leaders and militants.

Matrika is a maverick but not a fool. He realises that there is a political vacuum in Madhes with people unhappy with the state, Maoists, Madhesi parties and armed groups. He wants to set up a party that would allow him to get rid of the Maoist baggage but snatch away their landless base, besides tapping into the loyalties of other Yadavs. While some believe this is an elaborate Maoist ploy to set up Matrika as a radical face in Madhes by distancing themselves in public, others believe Matrika is too much of anarchist to become a cog in such a conspiracy.

And where does the Kathmandu establishment stand in all this? It is either totally insensitive or incompetent or is deliberately letting this fester. In their jumbo central committee, the unified Maoist party has less than a dozen Madhesi members. Think of the message this sends to the Tarai.

The presence of so many groups, with mixed motivations, will neither help the Madhes cause nor will it help the state assert its authority. Policymakers will end up prescribing easy solutions to increasingly intractable problems

Growing rage and discontent will translate into semi anarchy, ethnic and caste clashes, silencing of moderates and a continued call for secession from some quarters.

What Kathmandu can do is appoint a credible minister or task force for Tarai affairs that supervises developments there 24/7 – political grievances, local killings, micro disputes, administrative weakness, agreement implementation. Full time, sensitive, and sincere engagement with the plains is the only hope.




Entry filed under: Uncategorized.

Olga’s Girls – The Indentured Daughters of Nepal – I Blurred boundaries

4 Comments Add your own

  • 1. munna  |  January 27, 2009 at 7:02 am

    i think all writers and leaders are only talking about the problem of madhesh and are indulging in highlghting the weakness of madhesh.As far as Matrika yadav is concerned i think he has to be more responsible leader of terai because we are expecting alot from him.
    i somewhere agree with mr jha that every party of madhesh is trying to make their base strong and all…………………., but not its a time to find out solution of madhesh.Exactly what leader of madhesh want is not transparent, still there are some leader who are not clear with his ideology…, so i think instead of critisizing the leaders we should be pay more attention to find out the way to solve the issue of madhesh

  • 2. el magnifico  |  January 29, 2009 at 9:41 pm

    The so called armed groups do not seem to have a clear insinght of their mission and purpose.

    The second thing is they behave as per what they learned from maoist schooling not following the fact that the mission is different now.

    The third thing is they lack tactical skills of warefare. And they speak more but do less.

    Armed revolt has been in fact something that aids in the direction of change for centuries and throughout the world.
    Madhes ought not to be an exception.

  • 3. el magnifico  |  January 29, 2009 at 9:54 pm


    One can see readily clearly that a lot of changes happened to the madhesi people and their status just by declaration of armed struggle (by some groups ).

    One must comprehensively think on what changes the actual revolt can bring.
    I would like to say to madhesi leaders to find comprehensively solution to the small problems and go ahead.

    and at any cost do not compromise.
    I would highly appreciate any kind of comments (that makes sense)

  • 4. Janakpuri Hero  |  February 14, 2009 at 9:25 am

    El Magnifico,

    I don’t see how simply the declaration of armed struggle has brought a lot of changes to the status of madhesis as a whole. Definitely, the armed struggle has benefited a certain group, a small group though but overall, it has brought abductions, fear, lawlessness, extortions and murder to Madhesis as a whole.
    Some changes have come in the way Madhesis are labeled in the hilly regions but largely, they are still called by names such as ‘marsya’ and ‘dhoti’, the ‘nigger’ version as claimed by some. Changes have come to those who gained by gaining power by being elected as a CA member and thus gaining control over their region to secure re-election during parliamentary elections few years down the road.
    I don’t see how I have gained anything, how my neighbors have gained anything. I have not seen any of my neighbors, relatives, kiths, kins, even distant relatives getting any employment or benefiting in any way. Instead, my uncle was shot because he refused to pay unreasonable ransom to a little known armed group in Terai. My another uncle was sent several threatening SMS messages asking for ransoms to which he has not paid heed to. Even my dad received a threatening SMS message once but he didn’t pay heed to either.
    The armed struggle might have brought some sense of fear among the hilly origin people who might believe they are waging the struggle for the liberation of Madhes. But the truth remains, for Madhes, it has brought mass suffering and terror.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed

Celebration of 1,00,000

Madhesi Voice

United We Celebrate

People Celebrating faguwa (Holi), with the fun of music, quite popular among Terai people. Holi is celebrated each year on the eve of falgun purnima Faguwa (Holi) Celebration

Past Posts


Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 50 other followers

%d bloggers like this: